Talk:Vivienne de Tabris/@comment-33102809-20190302160639/@comment-35089194-20190804035149

The first reply seemed to make a point of ignoring what you (and Geralt) actually said, that there were no guarantees. Sure, she could live for 7 more years at the most, but she could also live the rest of her natural lifespan. Likewise, the curse could be permanently weakened within the Nice Guy™, or it could only be temporarily weakened. It's repeatedly spelled out that whatever choice is made, Geralt doesn't know what will happen in the long term.

I'm also not sure where they got the idea from that Guillaume dies if you go the egg route; that only occurs if you don't do the quest at all before its cut-off point. This is stated on his page and the quest page. I guess is reading is hard for some people.