Talk:The Black Cat and Dog/@comment-108.231.12.19-20170307183324/@comment-2601:247:C103:AC80:393E:F931:A82B:AD72-20171214130204

Don't be silly. We don't really know what they are. "Demons" is just someone's guess. And a very poor one at that, if you ask me. These creatures never displayed a hint of malevolence the entire time we see them. A more likely scenario is that, like the Caretaker, they're from some unknown place and not closely related to anything we know about in the rest of Witcher lore. But the fact that Iris wanted nothing to do with the Caretaker while she didn't mind these "animals" speaks well to them.

If you were to keep poor Iris in her hellish nightmare forevermore just because you're afraid these creatures that haven't displayed any malice or even attempted to manipulate Geralt are "demons", then the evil one is that scenario is not the talking animals.