Talk:A Knight's Tales/@comment-59.189.8.217-20161123141432

If you chose to lift the curse yourself at the very first opportunity, you will still have to kill the tree girl even if you have the bone. This is because Geralt technically does not know whose bone it is.

If you ask her nicely first then ask what happened to Gareth, Geralt will recognize Gareth body and will complete the ritual successfully.

There is no new quest log for that though. It's the same as when you ask the witch for help.