Thread:Mechemik/@comment-66.43.223.99-20180812065812/@comment-27075564-20180812221748

It's reallly just to keep game information consistent across all items. For example, swords: expereienced players know the damg. is based on level which is randomized and so there's no definite damg. set (with the exception of a few witcher items). However, we still get those who keep trying to add/change damg. despite this. I've also seen numbers for some of the potions themselves change based on if it's a NG or NG+ (just haven't had time to go back and find all the ones effected by this). Likewise, the amalagation page isn't meant to act as a detailed listing, it's meant to just generalize the information and, if one wants to know more, goes to that page (for example, the Acid extract page gets a lot of individual views because of its importance in crafting, despite being on an amalagation page as well).

The best we can do is add a note at the top warning, but for most they know to go to the individual page to learn more or of any bugs.