Talk:The Whispering Hillock/@comment-36811885-20180903161103

I thought the choice is obvious - saving the orphans girls who are totally innocent. Baron had probably killed lots of innocent peoples (and animals) during his baron activities or watsover. (Remember: he setup a fire which will cause deaths to alot of people AND horses if Geralt is not there for the rescue). Villagers of Downwarren? well might be innocent at the very beginning before crones/spirit activities but sacrificing children to be eaten, in order to protect their own arses? nonono. not to mention crones did hurt Ciri, who is my favorite, and the spirit actually at the very least honored her promise, and freed the children, turning into a horse which we didnt see any further consequences outside the quest, well at least in Wticher 3. Last but not least, the orphans girls helped Geralt selflessly in his quest, and Geralt should help them back (more so if you believe you are playing as a "good" Geralt), all the other parties helped Geralt selfishly, caring only themselves, so self-centered and wanted "more" in return. What pissed me off is that Baron was sooooooooooo fxxcking reluctant to reveal even a tiny bit of information about Ciri and only wanted Geralt to help him find his family. As for Anna, no comment, i just love Ciri / Yagna and company more than Anna.

As for glitched outcome (freeing spirit before going to the Earl-watever villager) you cant see the orphans again and i hate this bugged quest thingy in all pc games, so i wouldnt go for it.