Talk:In Wolf's Clothing/@comment-85.76.18.38-20180627182503

Getting both rewards is easy. However be warned: even if you kill Morkvarg after asking about the reward, the journal entry will not update (it still reads as if you let him walk away). Also the villagers chatter of a "pirate who returned to the seas.."

So if you're after immersion, I suggest you to either kill him immediately (with the dialogue choice) or if you ask for reward, let him walk.