Talk:Where the Cat and Wolf Play.../@comment-2602:306:CF60:6910:2158:EE8C:96C0:8D8C-20190717052317

This one was hard for me. Killing him is 100% deserved, I've killed humans who've done less shitty things in this game, and he did a very shitty thing. He's even worse than the Witcher you deal with in Lambert's quest: at least in that case the murder was years ago and you could argue one way or another the dude was trying to change. Gaetan killed all those people just a little while ago and feels absolutely no remorse whatsoever. At the same time, nothing indicated that he had any intention to actually cheat the villagers, and considering how deranged Cat School Witchers usually end up (emotionally unstable and extremely violent), that's genuinely saying something. In the end, I felt sparing him would be what Geralt would choose, and I have no doubt he'd know full well it's simply because Gaetan is a Witcher and Geralt knows how fucked up the mutations make them.