Talk:A Towerful of Mice/@comment-11990868-20190208013638/@comment-35089194-20190714224033

You've misunderstood both endings to this quest to such an extent that I'm not actually convinced you've even played it yourself. For starters, you apparently think there's an ending in which Anabelle's spirit remains on Fyke Isle. The only way her spirit could remain is if you don't do the quest at all. Second, you think the only consequence of taking her bones off the isle is that there's "another pesta out in the world", blatantly ignorant of the plague you've just unleashed. "''It is possible that this incident caused the local outbreak of Catriona that devastated the kingdom of Kerack and sowed the seeds of the coast city's ultimate downfall." ''No, you do not kill her later on.

How you misinterpreted the following dialogue to mean that Anabelle's spirit is still on Fyke Isle is beyond me:

Geralt: "Fyke Isle's free of it's curse." Keira: "Able to persuade Graham to go to the tower with you? Did you mention there was a pesta involved?" Geralt: "He knew the risks, but he'd also heard lots of stories about true love, whose kiss can break any spell. Can't help thinking that gave him courage." Keira: "And? It ended well?" Geralt: "Depends how you look at it. Curse is lifted, Anabelle's spirit has left in peace... but Graham's dead." Keria: "Oh, poor boy. Still, he's proved that true love may be more common than some suppose."

As with many quests in this game, there's certainly not an outright "Good" or "Bad" choice, but there sure as hell is a "Better" or "Worse" choice.