Talk:Yennefer/@comment-92.40.248.134-20150728180655/@comment-92.40.249.98-20150731064230

Well Geralt was with Yen in last wish which happened in 1250 he leaves her in 1251, so this is the only time she would get with Crach. But that could only of lasted a year as he tries to marry Pavetta's in 1252, but Geralt doesn't seem to know him, so the argument couldn't be then. Pavetta is pregnant with Ciri. Geralt said the argument happened before Cery's birth, and I'm sure she and Ciri are the same age.

Geralt could only learn of Crach and Yen is from Yen or Crach, yet Crach doesn't know Geralt, so if he was with Yen she never mentioned Geralt. He never returns to cintra, and never been to skellige. until 1259, he goes to cintra. Ciri is 6. Then he meets Yen for the first time in 4 years, now 1254. So he could only know of her and him from Yen, but Ciri and Cery's will be 1 or 2, too late for Crach argument.

Plus Yen never mentions she was with Crach, she is then sleeping with Istredd, so Geralt would not find out about Crach until God knows when. And as Cery's is similar ages with Ciri, Geralt would not know of Crach and Yen before her birth. So either that convo Cery's has with you is about Yen and you defending her, but not Crach and Yen's relationship, or a plot hole.