Talk:Shani/@comment-2A02:810D:900:10AC:888A:9360:4E8C:940D-20170714182903

I experienced that CDPR always preferes some choices from earlier witcher parts in their sequels, for example concerning Adda the story tells us about her death by default in The Witcher 2 and in fact a living Adda (altough mentioned by Foltest if you import a save) does not fit quite well into the story. Next in the third part we can tell from the situation and dialogues in Vizima that Geralt most likely chose to side with Roche in the second game. Now the question is, if you guys think the plot in The Witcher 2 and especially in Hearts of Stone expansion in The Witcher 3 references to a Triss or a Shani romance from the first game, since I could find piece of evidence for both sides.

For example there's a certain difference in the last dialogue with Shani during Hearts of Stone, which references the romance in different ways i linked videos with the regarding quotes below.

First: https://youtu.be/Mfdhk_Gw_hE?t=6m5s

Alternate: https://youtu.be/HQUfJp3OdPw?t=6s

I'm yet not sure what is causing this variation, but make your own thoughts and I'd be happy if you would share in the coments below. Btw which one did you prefer Triss or Shani ?