Talk:The Ghost in the Tree/@comment-71.120.174.21-20171207024858/@comment-27237080-20200127195205

You are not explaining anything, your opinion is based on the fact that there are simply debates, and that "stuff" is simply complicated, yet you have no clue whatsoever about it. I will ask you this so that you challenge your own mind - What is this debate all about exactly? Why do you think it means that anything is great? Ever thought that it can purely be just smething bad instead and it simply raises confusions to which people try to explain and justify their own choices rather than the meaning of the quest itself?

Just because something is complicated doesn't mean it makes something great, because you have to ask what sort of complication it is, or whether it is a complication to begin with, or just something is made wthout thinking it thoroughly.

It's a quest that surely challenges your moral compass, but then again, there is really not enough information to go on, neither options to explore. Personally when I get the option to think through I can't talk to Ladies about it and they are not putting any challenge for me like trying to tell their story, all they say is that there is a great evil andthat's it. How about an option where I get to ask what sort of evil it is in detail like a Witcher should, instead of not having option as if Geralt is fine with it and the town folk will explain, which the town folk didn't explained besides that there is a unknown mystery, yet obviously Ladies know everything that I need to know, but not the slightest info is given.

Imo this quest fails a challenge and more like "pick your door and see what you get, but you can't change your prize", of course we can reload the save, but the unflience here is long term rather than short term. Hence the reason why people even come here to debate, because they are looking for answers to which is lesser evil, or which one brings better outcome.

My point is, you have no idea what you're talking about, and when something feels complicated for you, it means that some genius did it, but you just fail at seeing issues. P.S. CDPR is great, but I wouldn't base that conclusion on this quest or just because something is complicated.