Talk:The Nithing/@comment-44882401-20200118061728/@comment-27237080-20200203233129

Well, he doesn't love her, and she will in time realize it doesn't matter if they are together if he does not love her and is just there just because, like he said when you meet them next time - I only agreed to that condition but not to love you. It still doesn't mean he can't visit his family and so on.

It's not ok to kill her as well since then it is a definitive murder, it was just something to which she admitted she wouldn't care if his son dies, doesn't say it was intentional at start, though she does not care.

But you know what? It's not 21st century, there are so many things that for us, now, feels absurd and dumb. Another thing is that this game has limited options/decisions and forced to choose between what is given, and not something we can input ourselves, decisions we would make naturally, words that we would use rather than what are given. Whether it would be for better or worse we don't know. I don't believe that one has to die at all, and I am playing the game as if I was Geralt, and as we all know the quote “Evil is Evil. Lesser, greater, middling… Makes no difference. The degree is arbitary. The definition’s blurred. If I’m to choose between one evil and another… I’d rather not choose at all.” We can interpret here as killing either child or the Jonna, by letting both live we choose to not choose any of those two evils.

That's how I see it, though either way it sucks for me, since for me, like I explained, it's not so black and white like it is for you, for you it's basically a revenge, you just need some justification for your reasons to make a revenge, it aint no better, since revenge is what Jonna did to the lover of hers. You really don't differ from it.

Either way, the guy probably would have killed her in some future anyway, one way or another...because he wont be able to be with her like that, and like you said, they are grownups, decisions are up to them. If he manages to kill her somehow, then it's fine, not our business as Witchers who shouldn't give a fuck wile people live, unless those are rapers and murderers like bandits, raiders, etc.