Talk:Dettlaff van der Eretein/@comment-94.197.120.185-20160615185955/@comment-82.132.246.184-20160701113130

Dettlaff had my sympathy up until he did what he did. He is capable of mayhem himself but brings an entire army to slaughter innocents. Including kids. He was too far gone at that point.

Yes, Geralt was labelled butcher of Blaviken wrongly, for trying to save people getting killed one by one. It could of benn avoided if Renfri told Geralt that this wasn't going to happen because Stregebor laughed in her face, saying she can kill everyone and would still not come out of his tower. Geralt didn't know that, so he killed them knowing they planned on slaughtering all Blaviken. The fault lies with Renfri playing with fire. As Geralt told her he won't let her kill innocents.

Well all Witcher schools are different as you know, and the Cat school are the worst. In Season of Storms short story, Geralt hears about the Striga contract on Foltest' daughter. A prelude to W1. When a man from the Cat school called Brehen wants that contract for himself, so he threatens Geralt in fighting him, which Geralt declines. Brehen then grabs a priestess and holds a knife to her throat and says he'll kill her, then slaughter the rest, one by one. He is only so brazen because Geralt had no swords. But Geralt gets his swords given back by a young sorceress, Tiziano Frevi. Geralt threatens to kill him if he don't leave, to which he does. The Cat witcher also thought Vesemir put a kill contract on him. Geralt says it's a lie, as witchers don't cross swords. But he will make an exception if he goes Cat crazy, like he did in Lello, and kill him.

Vesemir is like the nicest Witcher next to Geralt. Shows you he's paranoid.

Cat Witchers are all known for failed mutations, are all crazy, psychotic, with no qualms about slaughtering people. They're loose cannons and it's probably best they all die.

Gaetan from the Cat & Wolf play, is no different slaughtering a whole village for the crimes of 3 men. And spared one little girl only cause she reminded him of his sister.

Karadin from following the thread is also is dodgy. His story doesn't match up, and even if he don't deal with slaves no more, he still has those contacts, and still passes them on for others to deal, and have slaves.

All the Cat witchers should go extinct IMO.