Thread:Mechemik/@comment-38596938-20190223070206/@comment-3131473-20190223122551

I do like Phil in the novels actually. Not because of her sexapil (I like powerful women but not the abusive type), but because she is a clever politician with reasonable though not entirebly correct ideas, same as in the games.

Off-top aside: the wikis for long used to recognize mostly the books and CD Projekt games, but it was decided after years that due to enlarging number of adaptations (new TV series, non-Sapkowski novels, RPG games) they have to be more neutral. And to be neutral means accepting one canon, the one of the original creator. If you read throughout the articles, you can see we do not exclude adaptation info, we just add references to mark its origin. In cases when the info is uncertain, we mark it in the notes or trivia - and you are free to write a few sentences on her fate there.