Talk:The Witcher 3 decision checklist/@comment-45068227-20200217143532

There's an errror in the Whispering Hillock section. In the part about saving the spirit BEFORE talking to the ealdorman, they state regarding the orphans fate that "a dialogue element will give the impression that the orphans have been saved but this TURNS OUT NOT TO BE TRUE as there is no reference to the orphans' survival later in Novigrad as there normally is when they are saved."

That is absolutely just speculation and conejecture in lieu of concrete facts. You do not get to say "this isn't true" without absolute proof, and "there is no reference that they survived" is the absence of evidence, not evidence itself of their death. The proper thing to say is that "This is unknown" and not "This is untrue".