Talk:Lady of the Lake (nymph)/@comment-81.153.65.237-20171004235810/@comment-93.105.250.220-20190428130111

Indeed if Aerondight is your silver sword in Witcher 2, then Geralt loses it when he stabs the dragon in the mouth with it and it gets stuck in it. So even if it was super powerful you would not be able to keep it.

Which is why you get the "A Sword for Monsters" quest at the start of chapter 1.

The Moonblade however does stay with you if thats the sword you import. Aerondight however disappears because it would be the sword Geralt would be using by lore, hence it and the Witchers' silver sword, both work the same i.e. are lost if that's the one Geralt is using.