Talk:A Hallowed Horn/@comment-1582953-20160912082159/@comment-2A00:23C4:A499:B00:649F:A075:C560:86A6-20191118133205

Is it possible that things could be better resolved without Geralt having completed the quest? Kjarre mentions in the Thief Journal that he hopes to see Mathios at the equinox festival, so that he can return the horn to Holgerd, via him. He wants to make amends. Mathios also seems to see something decent in Kjarre.

I wonder if Kjarre and Mathios could potentially end up in the same map location at a later date, if Geralt doesn't ruin it by intervening/bringing the horn back first.

Maybe it's a mistake having Geralt take the horn, once you know that Kjarre wanted to return it.

Anyone know if failing this quest causes Kjarre to return the horn, himself? (..providing he's not dead)