Talk:A Knight's Tales/@comment-31647373-20170627153340/@comment-68.13.42.176-20181007041130

That's not a bug. When you talk to the witch, you have to select the 4th dialogue option to ask her about Gareth. If you do, Geralt will recognize the bones as Gareth's. If you don't, he'll wonder aloud as to whose they are, since he doesn't know Gareth's fate.