Talk:Fencing Lessons/@comment-136.32.22.129-20180818075927/@comment-185.245.87.165-20180908062554

I think the issue here is tribalism. They wanted to attack her because she was from the South. Her response was plotting a violent revenge against them, attempting to end that cycle of violence.

I understand there are different frames through which one can view the interaction, but remember that a running theme is that, as a witcher, Gerald is cold. He would not have had a compassionate reponse under any circumstances. The question is, are you in the moral right to mutilate two men for threatening violence? I would say no, though I do often wish for more nuanced responses, I understand the character is necessarily gruff.