Talk:A Knight's Tales/@comment-87.14.25.239-20160619081749/@comment-70.79.153.110-20160815091558

Confirmed. I haven't repeated this quest, but this page is missing the "best" ending. The way I did it:


 * Ask the witch about Gareth.
 * Ask the witch politely for help, but when she requires a lock of Geralt's hair, refuse, saying "I will lift the curse myself" (it may be okay to say that from the beginning, but althought I felt like giving her a chance, having seen the black magic doll I drew the line at giving her a lock of hair).
 * Enter the cave beneath the witch's hut and search for Gareth's body (ignore the quest log telling you to return to Jacob). Take a bone.
 * Return to Jacob and perform the ritual with the kerchief and the bone.
 * Tell Daphne's spirit that Gareth remained true to the end.

This ending is somewhat hidden in that you need to find Gareth's body by yourself, without the quest log showing you the way. That said, the cave is in a pretty conspicuous location and is the obvious place to look, and if you've been paying any attention at all you'll realize that you probably need to learn exactly what happened to Gareth, that the kerchief alone isn't going to be good enough.