Talk:Dettlaff van der Eretein/@comment-94.254.144.205-20171017103924/@comment-86.174.73.44-20171103214800

Whether he thinks like a human is neither here or there; the issue is what he does. If he doesn't want to be measured with a human measure then he shouldn't kill so many humans. Or sleep with one come to that. Sure, Dettlaff promises to stay away from humans but what is the word of a mass murderer worth? It's more than just being "not perfect good character," he's a raving, violent, unrepentant monster. And it's a Witcher's job to kill those.

As for the sisters not being better than him that's absurd. Syanna wanted the death of 5 people she had reason to personally hate. Bad, certainly, but not even close to engaging in a slaughter of completely uninvolved innocents just because one is angry. Plus Syanna at least shows (or can show) regret for her actions. Dettlaff doesn't even care. As for the other sister the worst thing you can say about Anna-Henrietta is that she loves her sister too much and was too scared to stand up to an injustice when she was a child. Hardly signs of great evil. Both sisters are morally superior to Dettlaff, Anna-Henrietta by a huge degree.