Talk:The Ghost in the Tree/@comment-24714925-20160530234659/@comment-27237080-20200127203024

This is similar to what I am trying to figure out here. Either this quest is a real moral challenge, which it isn't, or the developers didn't bothered to make sense out here and give options for obtaining more information considering how much of an impact it deals. I have no option to ask Crones about this evil spirit, which obviously they know about. Willagers are not saying much because Crones are listening. The spirit trapped is not saying anything as well which would give a decent Witcher what he requires....information, especially for Geralt, where it is said in lots of places that being cautious and being informed, or something like that, is something he has learned over the years of expeirence. Developers fail to give me the sensible options that Geralt should have - questioning details.

I dislike this quest since I have no way to confront Crones or ask about this spirit, all they do is send me to a village who, as far as I understand, lies, just as well as Crones, but pretty convincingly, yet I have no way to gain knowledge about anything that as a smart and sensible person should require, especially someone as Geralt.

This doesn't even play "lesser evil" kind of choice, neither gives the neutral path that first witcher had, something that side characters and other primary characters tend to point out time to time of their "famous" neutrality, something even the second game still had.