Talk:The Ghost in the Tree/@comment-91.157.229.206-20150708144349/@comment-27237080-20200127211611

It differs from person to person, hence why there were options to get to know Baron, and some people can see a reason to forgive and give a second chance, others on the other hand are like you, who just can't stand it right from the first time. And then there are many other types of people who either like him right away, dislike him right away, doesn't care about neither of options and is just there for money or whatnot, or any other reason and personality. Personally, after hearing him out, and the way how I play with Geralt, I tend to give second chances depending on some variables that I have in decisionsand the info I have been given + my moral compass, but if it repeats, and I have at least the decency of having the option to say that "I gave you a second chance to stop it, but you ignored it, so face it now...", then I would do it, but again, depending of variables and info given, whether the story was set up that maybe the man had no choice this time, or something like that.

Basically what I am trying to say is - It depends. :D :D  too many things are involved in decision making, and game is set in few of possible options unlike the options you would like to have, or actual real life options that would present depending of the info given and possibiltiies of obtaining that info in order to expand on the possible options and decisions.