Talk:Triss Merigold/@comment-19281228-20160629030655/@comment-19281228-20160630000216

Yes, I think a strong case can be made either way.

One could argue that, while Yen and Geralt "have more history", it is only because Geralt made a foolish wish to a Genie whilst infatuated with Yen. This unholy magic bound them. The journal also mentions how their 15+ year history was full of bitter arguments and breakups. I interpret this as a classic case of "be careful what you wish for" - Geralt made a huge mistake making that wish and had to live with the consequences. Breaking the Genie curse was the best thing to ever happen in TW3 - it freed Geralt and allowed him to pursue his true love - whether that is Triss or Yen (i.e. based on the player's choice).

In terms of having better chemisty and kindred souls - that's pretty subjective. I felt like the chemisty between Triss and Geralt was far stronger. Yen felt more like a boss than a lover - ordering Geralt around like a little pawn. Triss just treats Geralt better. Like an equal - not a slave or a piece of property. All around, I felt Triss to be much more pleasent to be around. Subjective, I know.

And yes, both have done "sketchy things", but Yen's are pretty bad: theft, necromancy, and euthanasia - to name a few. But, one could sit around and make a rolodex of sins for either Triss or Yen - neither is perfect.

Ultimately, you're right - people have to choose what feels right for them. I like to make the case for Triss, but I know that other people think and feel differently. There is no "right and wrong" - both lead to a happy ending. And it is why I am so glad that game gives the player a choice! :)